Skip to main content

EdUHK Study Finds Residual Antibiotics in Cooked Food

The use of veterinary antibiotics is not uncommon in the fields of animal husbandry and fisheries to speed up growth and prevent disease. However, residual antibiotics may damage human gut microbiota, promote antibiotic resistance, and even delay the growth and development of brain cells, posing hazards to human health.

 

Since 2015, Dr Deng Wenjing, Associate Professor in the Department of Science and Environmental Studies at The Education University of Hong Kong (EdUHK), and her research team have been examining the use of antibiotics and their impact in the context of local environmental ecology, food safety and children's health. They have found that these practices not only cause water pollution, but also contaminate food, eventually affecting human health. 

 

Environmental ecology


In 2021, the research team collected 13 river water samples and 15 sea water samples across Hong Kong. The results showed that the samples were extensively contaminated with antibiotics, including tetracyclines (three types), sulfonamides (10 types), quinolones (nine types), and macrolides and streptomycin. Some types were detected in all samples. In areas with a larger number of farms, such as Yuen Long (see Table 1), both the number of types and the concentration of antibiotics detected were higher. Compared to the initial study in 2015, the team found that the concentration rate of target antibiotics had decreased, but antibiotics were detected in more locations, indicating a broader coverage of antibiotics in local waters.  

 

Children's health


In other research in 2016, the team collected 31 urine samples from local children aged between four to six. None of them had taken any medical antibiotics within a month before the test, but 77.4% of their samples were found to be positive for antibiotics, with the highest concentration reaching 0.36 ng/mL. The detection rate was higher than that in Shanghai and Korea (see Table 2). Although the levels of concentration were lower than the World Health Organisation’s international standard, other studies have revealed a significant correlation between the use of antibiotics in animals and children being overweight or obese. The situation, therefore, should not be ignored. 

 

Food safety

 

To examine the relationship between food safety and the consumption of antibiotics in animals by children, the team tested in the same year chicken, pork, freshwater and saltwater seafood, and organic eggs bought from markets near the residences of the surveyed children. The team discovered that using traditional cooking methods, such as boiling, slow cooking, stir-frying, roasting, and steaming, did not remove antibiotics from the food.

Tetracyclines and streptomycin were also found in ‘organic eggs’ with ‘free from antibiotics' claims, which could have been contaminated during packaging. This is in addition to the low concentration rate of oxytetracycline detected in drinking water, which indicates that the use of antibiotics in animals has already impacted our daily life on various fronts. 


Dr Deng said, “The aim of these studies is to understand the use of antibiotics in animals in Hong Kong. They have revealed that even after high-temperature cooking, antibiotics cannot be completely removed from food, and ultimately enter the human body, posing a threat to our health" 
She called on parents to take heed of the excessive intake of antibiotics, which could alter the intestinal environment and even lead to antibiotic resistance. More research in this area and frequent food testing are needed to understand the health risks of antibiotics on children. In the long run, it is necessary to strengthen regulatory control in this area to prevent the situation from worsening.

 

Table 1: Antibiotic concentrations detected in Hong Kong in 2021 (ng/L)

Sampling sites

Water

Sulfonamides

(SAs)

Sulfonamides

(TCs)

Fluoroquinolones

(FQs)

Macrolides

(MLs)

Others

Total

1

Sam Mun Tsai

River

6.04

7.73

13.83

1.89

6.09

35.58

2

Lam Tsuen River

River

7.03

7.38

10.06

0.77

1.25

26.48

3

Lam Tsuen River2

River

8.32

8.46

13.01

0.18

2.72

32.68

4

Tai Po River

River

7.06

7.14

7.42

1.32

22.94

5

Shing Mun River

River

11.31

7.48

7.70

0.16

3.80

30.46

6

Shing Mun River2

River

26.84

4.35

15.62

30.00

1.28

78.08

7

Ng Tung River

River

15.60

6.54

5.59

27.73

8

Sheung Yue River

River

3.44

7.96

3.30

14.69

9

Sheung Yue River2

River

66.32

12.94

34.50

0.50

114.26

10

Kam Tin River

River

16.30

23.53

16.24

5.26

2.15

63.48

11

Kam Tin River2

River

11.53

6.09

9.91

27.53

12

Shan Pui River

River

2.87

3.81

4.64

2.34

4.79

18.45

13

Hang Hau Tsuen

River

2.28

2.27

3.36

7.90

14

Lung Kwu Tan Rd

Sea

3.81

6.89

7.22

0.27

1.54

19.72

15

Castle Peak Rd-Tsing Lung Tau

Sea

10.13

2.23

7.44

2.01

5.90

27.71

16

Tung Chung River

Sea

4.06

1.73

4.38

0.98

9.92

21.06

17

Wong Lung Stream

Sea

3.61

1.82

4.89

1.74

1.25

13.31

18

N Lantau Hwy

Sea

3.35

2.94

4.12

0.82

0.57

11.80

19

Tsing Sheung Rd

Sea

3.25

2.87

9.12

16.77

32.00

20

North Point Ferry Pier

Sea

5.12

10.19

10.30

0.51

26.11

21

Central Ferry Pier No.7 (Star Ferry Pier)

Sea

4.32

7.10

6.90

18.32

22

Clear Water Bay Second Beach

Sea

1.93

4.85

3.17

9.95

23

Hiu Po Path

Sea

2.19

5.46

4.93

12.58

24

Pak Shan Wan St

Sea

2.51

5.03

3.39

10.93

25

Tso Wo Hang Pier

Sea

1.67

4.87

2.97

9.51

26

Kei Ling Ha Lo Wai

Sea

2.36

5.71

3.85

11.92

27

Wu Kai Sha Pebbles Beach

Sea

2.79

5.82

7.62

16.23

28

Luk Keng Rd

Sea

1.98

4.71

5.52

12.20

 

Table 2Antibiotic residues in children's urine in Hong Kong, Shanghai and Korea

Hong Kong

Shanghai

Korea

Study year

2017

2015

2007

Study institutes

EdUHK

Fudan University

Seoul University

No. of antibiotic type detected

13

20

6

Concentration in children’s urine

0-0.36 ng/mL

0.1-3.0 ug/mL

0-0.16ng/mL

Detection rate

77.4%

56.0%

67.9%

No. of children participants

31

284

99

Children age

4-6

8-11

7-12

 

Table 3Antibiotic residues in raw and cooked food (ng/g

Pork

Chicken

Fish

Shrimp

Organic eggs

Organic Chicken

raw

after

raw

after

raw

after

raw

after

raw

after

raw

after

Tetracycline (TC)

6.7

2.9

5.7

3.9

7.0

0

0

0

6.6

0

0

0

Doxycycline (DTC)

5.9

0

3.5

0

0

0

0

0

1.7

0

0

0

Oxytetracycline (OTC)

5.8

0

28.5

28.5

2.5

2.5

0

0

0

0

0

0

Penicillin (PEN)

6.5

6.5

6.8

0

3.5

1.6

1.1

1.1

0

0

1.3

1

Erythromycin (ETM)

2.1

2.1

2.3

1.3

0.6

0.6

0.9

0.9

2.0

2

1.3

0

Sulfamethoxazole (SMX)

3.8

3.8

1.5

1.5

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Enrofloxacin (EFC)

2.6

2.6

2.4

2.4

3.1

2.1

0

0

0

0

0

0

Ciprofloxacin (CIP)

3.1

3.1

4.2

4.2

1.1

2.1

0

0

0

0

0

0

Ofloxacin (OFC)

0

0

0

2.5

1.7

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Total

36.5

21

54.9

44.3

19.5

8.9

2

2

10.3

2

2.6

1

 

- ENDS- 

 

Dr Deng Wenjing, Associate Professor in the Department of Science and Environmental Studies at EdUHK
Dr Deng Wenjing, Associate Professor in the Department of Science and Environmental Studies at EdUHK